In honor of
National Poetry Month, I thought I would take a minute to explain exactly why it is that I love the poem from yesterday's post, Philip Larkin's
Trees, so much. So take out a pen and a notebook. This
will be on the exam.
I think that this poem is a lovely counterpart to another favorite poem of mine,
Spring and Fall: To a Young Child. That's the one where the trees losing their leaves in fall remind Gerard Manley Hopkins of his own mortality. In
Trees, the new growth of leaves in spring reminds Philip Larkin of his own mortality. Basically, everything reminds poets of their own mortality.
That's why, at the end of the first verse, Philip Larkin says that the greenness of the trees is "a kind of grief": because it reminds him that people, unlike trees, don't die and come back again. But then he goes on to say that trees don't actually do this either. They're not dying in winter and being reborn in spring; they're aging just like we do. Every year they produce new leaves, but they also produce another ring of wood, a sign that they're getting older.
The tree is like a poet not just because it's mortal, but also because in this poem everything it produces is verbal. The new leaves are like someone beginning to speak, "like something almost being said." The tree rings are "written down." It's also a safe bet, when interpreting a poem, that everything reminds the poet of writing poetry.
So the tree putting forth leaves in the spring isn't, for Philip Larkin, a symbol of death and rebirth. It's more like a poet who continues to write poetry -- to work and live as if he were continually being reborn, even though he's aging.
Which brings me to the last verse. What is going on with those castles and their threshing? I think Philip Larkin is talking about the idea that, in the Middle Ages, castles would line their stone floors with grasses, the product of threshing. I've read that this didn't actually happen. But I still think it's what Larkin is comparing the trees to here. Imagine huge dark castles that bring in thick carpets of new-mown grass every spring. As the year goes on, the grass turns to straw, and then when spring comes again a new carpet of green is laid down. The trees renew themselves every year in just the same way.
The last line of this poem is the best. "Begin afresh, afresh, afresh." It's repeated so many times because that is how the cycle of the seasons, and of human life, works: you must begin afresh over and over again. But it's also repeated because this line, unlike the rest of the poem, is spoken in a different voice. The poet isn't speaking here; he's telling you what the trees are saying, and that's why the last line sounds like the rustle of leaves in the wind. Philip Larkin was so brilliant.